If Olivia is sympathetic to the monster's plight, she isn't showing it right now. Sure, she's trying to keep an open mind towards the whole situation, but if Flupper was really desperate for love, he should've asked for help instead of attempting a broad daylight kidnapping.

Thanking her lucky stars for now, she's left standing there, staring blankly at Carter for a brief moment. And then she realizes what things had to be said to get her free. Oops.

"Yeah, I'll be okay now that he's gone..." She's embarrassed and frustrated at letting herself be kidnapped so easily. "Sorry for dragging you into my mess. If there's any way I can make it up to you, please let me know."